It's one of those moments that marks the change of a man's life.
In the movie Walk the Line, the actor playing country music legend Johnny Cash is stopped abruptly during an audition by the actor playing record producer Sam Phillips, with words that chill to the bone:
"I don't believe you."
The Phillips character goes on the scold the Cash character for singing a me-too gospel song with no passion, no intensity, no connection with the message of the music.
Johnny's not a quitter. In the kind of magic transformation that we mostly only see in movies, the superstar-to-be sings another song that leads to a studio recording the same day... and launches a career.
Well, so much for the movies. What about real life?
Not so fast there, my demanding reader. First let's take a pit stop at a midpoint.
USA Today of October 13, 2005 reports that something very similar happened between actors themselves in the making of a movie.
Reporter Scott Bowles relates that during the making of Two for the Money, actor Matthew McConaughey got an unexpected acting lesson from master of the craft Al Pacino.
"'Once we were doing a scene, and suddenly, right in the middle of the take, he stops and looks at me and says "I don't believe you,"' McConaughey says. 'That'll stop you in your tracks. When Al Pacino tells you that he doesn't believe you, you believe it.'"
Well, that's very nice. Rich Hollywood stars, busting each others' chops.
But wait. This really does have something to do with copywriting.
A lot, in fact.
I remember a quote from one of the greatest copywriters of the 20th century, James Webb Young:
"Every advertiser has the same problem: to be believed."
Indeed, isn't that the crux of the matter?
When you are reading copy, you like what you see, you want what is offered, you can somehow find a way to afford it, and you believe what you read... what's stopping you from going ahead and buying?
Nothing.
In fact, that's when you buy.
And so it is with your prospects.
The question is, how do you write copy that people really believe?
My view is that the answer is twofold.
Fold one is technical.
Fold two -- often overlooked, but vitally important -- is emotional.
There are many techniques that create believability in copy. Well-phrased testimonials from credible sources. Proof in the form of test results, technical specs, media mention. Personal credibility through professional degrees, books published, awards given.
That's the first half.
But the second half has much more to do with YOU, the copywriter.
Do YOU believe what you're saying?
Do YOU believe it's the right thing for your prospect to buy?
Do YOU believe it enough to give your all, push past your limits, hang out in the discomfort of being a little outrageous and otherwise extreme, to get your prospect to see and know how you really feel?
This, of course, would require that you actually believe in what you're selling.
What a concept.
Now I'm enough of a realist to know that for-hire copywriters don't always find themselves in that position.
Yes, you can still make your copy believable when you're in that position. My only advice to you there is to find a way to free yourself from having to promote things YOU don't fully believe in.
And, you do the best you can with what you've got, where you are.
When I first started writing advertising sales copy 20 years ago, I was still strongly under the influence of my previous career as a journalist.
Because I went through rigorous fact-checking before I wrote articles for publication, I KNEW what I was writing was true. (Or was it that I merely believed it, albeit very strongly?)
As a copywriter, it shocked me that people wouldn't necessarily believe me just because I stated the truth.
But as I learned the techniques of persuasion and I began to put more of my passion into my writing, I started to get the results I had expected all along.
As you go for better and better results yourself, keep these things in mind. They really can change your outcomes in a positive new direction.
So...
Does believability make a difference in the effectiveness of your copy?
You better believe it does.
Cheers,
David Garfinkel
Publisher, World Copywriting Newsletter