What would you call a motionless potato with two eyes watching college football on ESPN from a living-room couch all day long this past Saturday?
You would call that couch potato: me.
As a University of Michigan alum, I can't keep my eyes off the roller-coaster fortunes of my school's tortured Wolverines team. And last weekend's Ohio State and USC games were of peripheral interest to me as well.
So. In between bouts of football came the commercials. I saw the Taco Bell ad so many times I almost know the older brother's rules by now (which I should know, being the older brother in my family). But I still can't remember the name of the product he was trying to sell.
Two other commercials really stood out, however. Even though they thoroughly violate the headline-hook-offer-call^to^action orthodoxy of direct response copy. Direct response copy is my bailiwick in business and in this blog. Nevertheless, they represented such good examples of selling via media that I have to commend them, rulebreakers that they are.
Listen.
Great commercial #1 was for the Ford Escape SUV, which is a hybrid. Think "green." I have a retailer client doing more business than you could ever imagine out of a single storefront location. He tells me, "You have no idea how big the green movement is among consumers right now."
I believe him.
Ford's ad rides the Green Wave flawlessly.
A dad with an out-of-sorts teenage daughter walk towards the vehicle. Girl to Dad: "Could you let me off a block before we get to the theatre? All the people there are on bicycles or hybrids."
Clearly, she's ashamed of her insensitive pig father's gas-guzzling greenhouse-gas-emitting minesweeper.
Cut to a close-up of the back of the vehicle. Focus on word "HYBRID."
This is an SUV, remember.
Hmmmm. Inside, Dad, now pulling out of driveway, to Girl: "But this is a hybrid."
Girl to Dad, "You mean like a hybrid hybrid?"
Dad, laughing, to Girl: "I don't know what you mean by a 'hybrid hybrid,' but, yes, it is."
Girl, thinking. Then, to Dad: "Why didn't you ever tell me?"
Dad: "I didn't think I needed to."
Maybe to you as you read this is comes across as hokey. On the little screen, it's not. (Dialogue and screenplay from memory.)
This commercial is powerful. Why? Because for Dads (and Moms), it promises social insurance against the embarrassment of being labeled a greenhouse-gas-emitting environmental criminal while still having the status and security (and road dominance) of an SUV.
That will sell a lot of Ford Escapes. Brilliant.
Great commercial #2: Digitally modified videos of real people talking, made to look like cartoons. They're talking about stockbrokers. They like their broker but they are uneasy about the fees. They feel like they're unfairly charged. You get the impression that their brokers are a private-sector version of the Beatles' Taxman: Ding you if you breathe, ding you if you hold your breath.
Then, the blissfully better comparison: Charles Schwab has no hidden fees. No "inactivity" fees if you don't touch your account. No breathing fees. No hold-your-breath fees.
A classic winning example of the Grudge USP I've written about before, but I'm not sure where. I introduced this concept for the first time at Tactic 7, the seminar I did with Harlan Kilstein and John Carlton last year.
The Grudge USP works like this:
- Find out what grudges your customers hold against your competitors
- Actively do the opposite
- Tell your customers about it
OK, there you have it -- two great commercials.
But despite those moments of light, it was a lousy day for the couch potato. The Wisconsin Badgers beat the Michigan Wolverines to a pulp.
David Garfinkel
Publisher, World Copywriting Newsletter